30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (2024)

*This post may have affiliate links, which means I'll receive a commission if you purchase through my link, at no extra cost to you. Please read full disclosure.

Want to feel like a real-life fairy? Dive into these fairy makeup ideas that are so gorgeous, you won’t believe your eyes. Time to get magical!

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (1)

Ever dreamt of stepping into a world of magic and wonder?

Fairy makeup is your ticket to an ethereal, glittering world where you can totally shine!

And let’s be real, if you’re looking for some cute Halloween makeup, these fairy looks are exactly what you need to transform your vibe.

Think shimmering glitter, soft pastels, and all the mystical feels you could ever want.

Plus, these fairy looks are right up there with our faves like dreamy clown makeup, classic witchy glam, and those super cool skeleton vibes.

Ready to dive into a world of fantasy and sparkle?

Let’s check out the best fairy makeup ideas that are so gorgeous, they might just make you believe in magic! ✨

What Is Fairy Makeup?

Okay, but like, what even is fairy makeup? It’s basically about embracing your inner magical creature and just having fun with it.

Imagine all the sparkling glitter, soft pastels, and delicate designs you can think of.

It’s perfect for adding a bit of fantasy to your everyday look or going all out for something special.

The coolest part? There are no rules. You can go wild with colors, pile on the glitter, or keep it super chill—it’s totally up to you.

Fairy makeup is all about making your look as unique and magical as you are!

What Are Must-Have Products for Fairy Makeup?

If you’re ready to glow up like a fairy, here are some must-have products that’ll take your look to the next level. Trust me, you’re gonna want these in your makeup bag:

What Are the Best Fairy Makeup Ideas?

So, you’re ready to get your fairy on? Let’s dive into the best fairy makeup ideas that will have you looking straight out of a magical forest:

1. Minty Butterfly Eyes

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (2)

recreate the look

This look is all about fresh vibes! Soft mint eyeshadow paired with delicate butterfly accents gives you that dreamy, fairy-tale feel. Perfect for when you want to keep it cool and magical.

2. Icy Crystal Fairy

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (5)

recreate the look

Channel those winter wonderland feels with icy blue tones and crystal-like sparkles. It’s like stepping out of a frosty fairy tale, where everything glows with a cool, ethereal light.

3. Enchanted Green Fairy

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (7)

recreate the look

Green never looked so enchanting! This one’s for those who love nature-inspired magic. Emerald greens and subtle gem touches make you look like you just emerged from a magical forest.

4. Snowy Butterfly Gaze

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (11)

recreate the look

All white everything, with a butterfly twist! Snowy white eyeshadow mixed with fluttery white butterfly details gives off a pure, ethereal vibe. It’s like a winter fairy kissed by snowflakes.

5. Blushing Pink Fairy

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (14)

recreate the look

Pink, but make it fairy! Soft, rosy shades and a little sparkle here and there make this look totally enchanting. It’s sweet, cute, and oh-so-pretty.

6. Ocean Blue Wings

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (17)

recreate the look

This one’s for the ocean lovers. Deep blue shades with a touch of shimmer create wings that are both bold and beautiful. It’s like bringing the sea’s magic right to your eyes.

7. Sparkling Winged Look

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (20)

recreate the look

Glitter, glitter, and more glitter! This look is all about adding sparkle to your eyes with shimmery wings that catch the light. It’s playful, fun, and perfect for any fairy vibe.

8. Gem-Studded Butterfly Eyes

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (23)

recreate the look

Why settle for just glitter when you can add gems too? Tiny, shimmering gems placed around your eyes make this butterfly-inspired look pop with a touch of glam.

9. Lavender and Gold Magic

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (26)

recreate the look

Soft lavender meets warm gold in this dreamy combo. It’s delicate, magical, and ideal for anyone who loves a soft, glowing fairy look with a hint of luxury.

10. Fiery Orange Butterfly

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (29)

recreate the look

Bring the heat with this bold, orange butterfly-inspired look. Bright, fiery shades mixed with subtle butterfly accents make this look stand out with a burst of energy and fun.

11. Pure White Fairy

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (32)

recreate the look

All about that angelic vibe! Soft white shades paired with subtle shimmers make this look totally pure and enchanting. It’s like being wrapped in a cloud of fairy magic.

12. Whimsical Mushroom Fairy

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (34)

recreate the look

For those who love a playful, quirky vibe! This look features rich reds with soft whites, giving that classic mushroom fairy aesthetic. It’s all about embracing the cute and magical side of nature with a hint of whimsy.

13. Mystical Woodland Spirit

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (37)

recreate the look

Deep and mysterious, this look uses earthy tones with a hint of dark magic. Perfect for channeling those mystical forest vibes where everything feels a bit magical and wild.

14. Dark Fairy Glam

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (40)

recreate the look

Adding some drama for those who dare! Deep eyeliner paired with striking red lips gives off a fierce, glamorous vibe with just the right amount of edge. This look blends fairy magic with a bold, wicked twist.

15. Soft Simple Beauty

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (43)

recreate the look

Sometimes, less is more. This look keeps it super soft and natural, with gentle tones that highlight your natural beauty. It’s like being a fairy in the most effortless way possible.

16. Youthful Rosy Fairy

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (45)

recreate the look

Fresh and rosy with soft pinks that give a healthy, glowing finish. Sweet, fun, and totally capturing that “just blushed” vibe that’s absolutely adorable.

17. Sunflower Glow

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (48)

recreate the look

Bright and sunny, just like a sunflower! Warm yellows and golden hues create a cheerful, glowing vibe, bringing a touch of summer sunshine right to your face.

18. Royal Purple Princess

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (50)

recreate the look

Get ready for a royal moment! Rich purples combined with a hint of sparkle give off serious princess vibes. It’s all about feeling regal and magical at the same time.

19. Black Butterfly Accent

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (52)

Dark and moody, with a twist! Deep, midnight shades paired with a bold butterfly accent create a look that’s mysterious and totally captivating. Perfect for late-night magic.

20. Modern Blue and White Lines

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (53)

Sleek and cool with a touch of futurism. Crisp white and light blue lines give this look a modern fairy feel, like something out of a high-fashion fairy tale.

21. Daisy Dream Fairy

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (54)

Bright, fresh, and full of life! Yellows and whites paired with daisy accents create a sweet, dreamy vibe, great for capturing that airy, fairy feel.

22. Shimmering Gray Wings

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (55)

Subtle yet striking, this look is all about those shimmering gray tones. Fantastic for when you want something elegant with just a touch of sparkle that still catches everyone’s eye.

23. White Liner Magic

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (56)

A simple yet stunning look using crisp white liner to make your eyes pop. It’s a fresh twist on fairy makeup, giving off those clean and cool vibes that are totally chic.

24. Pastel Princess Glow

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (57)

Soft pastels mixed with a radiant glow, this look is all about being delicate and dreamy. Ideal for those who want to feel like a princess with a soft, magical touch.

25. Futuristic Fantasy Look

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (58)

Shiny metallics and edgy lines give off major sci-fi vibes. With a sleek design and magical sparkle, you’ll totally feel like a fairy from the future. Perfect for those who love a mix of modern chic and otherworldly charm!

26. Unicorn Wings Fantasy

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (59)

If you’re dreaming of a unicorn vibe, pastel colors and sparkles can bring that fantasy to life. This look flutters with whimsy, giving you all the magical feels.

27. Winged Tiara Queen

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (60)

For a fairy queen vibe, your look can shine with pastel lines and a majestic winged tiara. This enchanting style adds elegance and makes you feel like pure fairy royalty.

28. Rainbow Sparkle Fairy

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (61)

Imagine turning every day into a color festival. With rainbow hues and glitter, you’ll be spreading cheerful vibes and magical sparkles wherever you go.

29. Metallic Blue Wings

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (62)

Bold metallic blue wings bring a cool edge to your fairy style. With a sleek, shiny finish, these wings are all about making a statement. Ideal for those who want to blend glamor with a bit of rebellious flair!

30. Scarlet Butterfly Center

30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (63)

A bold scarlet butterfly at the center of your look makes a dramatic statement. With vivid, rich colors and a touch of elegance, this style adds a fierce and fabulous flair.

Fairy Makeup Ideas: FAQs

Got some burning questions about nailing that perfect fairy look? You’re not alone! Here are the top FAQs to help you slay your fairy makeup:

Q: How Do You Get That Soft, Ethereal Glow?

To get that dreamy, glowing look, we like to use a bit of liquid highlighter on the high points of my face—cheekbones, brow bones, and maybe the tip of my nose.

Just blend it out with your fingers or a sponge for that natural, lit-from-within finish.

And if you add a touch of shimmer eyeshadow on your lids, it really makes everything pop!

Q: Which Colors Work Best for Fairy Makeup?

Pastels are always a go-to for fairy vibes—think pinks, lilacs, and blues.

But honestly, it’s fun to mix in some golds, silvers, or even brighter colors if you’re feeling bold.

It’s all about keeping the look light and magical—like airy, not heavy.

Q: How Do You Keep Face Gems and Stickers from Falling Off?

We’ve found that starting with clean, dry skin helps a lot.

And if you use a little bit of eyelash glue or any skin-safe adhesive, those gems will stay put all night.

Just press them gently for a few seconds to make sure they’re secure, and you’re good to go!

Wrap Up

Fairy makeup ideas are all about getting creative and having fun. Whether you’re into a mystical vibe or something more chill, there’s a fairy look here for you this Halloween. So, find your favorite and let your imagination take over!

Craving more Halloween makeup ideas?

  • 40 Super Cute Halloween Makeup Ideas That Are Scarily Adorable
  • 35+ Super Easy Halloween Makeup Ideas Anyone Can Pull Off!
30 Mystical Fairy Makeup Ideas That Are Too Gorgeous to Be Real | Everygirl Edit (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Zonia Mosciski DO

Last Updated:

Views: 5858

Rating: 4 / 5 (51 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Zonia Mosciski DO

Birthday: 1996-05-16

Address: Suite 228 919 Deana Ford, Lake Meridithberg, NE 60017-4257

Phone: +2613987384138

Job: Chief Retail Officer

Hobby: Tai chi, Dowsing, Poi, Letterboxing, Watching movies, Video gaming, Singing

Introduction: My name is Zonia Mosciski DO, I am a enchanting, joyous, lovely, successful, hilarious, tender, outstanding person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.